Album Review: Joe Nichols – It’s All Good

Karlie Justus Marlowe | November 17th, 2011

joenicholsitsallgoodA popular compliment for particularly talented artists is the old line about singing the alphabet: Armed with enough talent and charisma, some singers could make it all the way from A to Z and still aptly hold the attention of their fans.

Joe Nichols is certainly one of those vocalists, possessing a set of pipes both as impressive and understated as neo-traditional forefathers Keith Whitley, Alan Jackson and George Strait. But when an artist’s song selection becomes as predictable and one-note as that preschool staple, that blind appeal begins to chip away.

Both sides of that coin are present on Nichols’ new album It’s All Good, a lean offering of ten new songs and his first studio album since 2009. A classic example of a headphone record, Nichols’ smooth, rich voice and the sweet strains of steel guitar are presented in a quiet, understated collection of sleepy songs that demand a closer look. The nuance on this record becomes especially important amidst a monotonous pick of storylines and production choices, as charming as they may be.

The album’s slowest moments cover much of the same tired territory. “The More I Look,” in the weathered barfly stylings of Toby Keith, and the aw-shucks “This Ole Boy” are pleasant-sounding retreads, while lead-off single “Take It Off” is fun but forgettable. These tunes crowd lyrics into tight spaces, and rely on convention over content.

But in his sweet spot – when sonic form and lyrical function equal each other – Nichols shines: standout track “Somebody’s Mama” matches its singer’s talent with an attention-grabbing opening narrative that morphs into a bittersweet twist on its title. Similarly, “Never Gonna Get Enough” recalls George Jones’ “Tennessee Whiskey,” detailing a love that reaches the highs of the hard stuff with none of the hangover, and the title track “It’s All Good” quietly works. It sounds like it may have narrowly escaped the clutches of Strait, with Nichols easily making it his own with steel guitar and a gritty grin.

However, that in-the-pocket simplicity is also a double-edged sword: There’s not a huge gulf between the good and bad, with quite a bit of middling and meh in between. In the end, It’s All Good is a pleasant album by a talented artist, where everything sounds good but nothing stands out.

3 Stars

Preview or purchase It’s All Good

  1. Ben Foster
    November 17, 2011 at 9:23 am

    I’ve only heard this album once, but my impression was the same. “Somebody’s Mama” definitely grabbed my attention, but the other songs didn’t really pop much. “Take It Off” doesn’t really do anything for me, and “This Ole Boy” wasn’t very interesting when Craig Morgan sang it either. It’s not a terribly bad album, but it’s largely disposable.

  2. bob
    November 17, 2011 at 11:36 am

    I remember when he started out he was being compared to Gene Watson. I like his voice but there are tracks I don’t care for at all on this cd – 1,2,5 & 8.

  3. Ken Morton, Jr.
    November 17, 2011 at 12:40 pm

    Karlie, your review hits this album right on the head. Nice work on this review. “Somebody’s Mama” was a stand-out track for me as well. I also really liked “She’s Just Like That.” That particular track reminded me a lot of Garth Brooks’ “She’s Every Woman” with its adoring lyrics to a lady who is “honeysuckle sweet but boy she’s a ball of fire.” The balance of the album wasn’t overly memorable.

  4. luckyoldsun
    November 19, 2011 at 12:11 am

    It’s good of Joe to review his own album. I might have titled it “It All Sucks.”

Tagged In This Article

// // // // //

Current Discussion

  • Daniel Mullins: Mr. Mazor- In your opinion, who do you think will be/should be inducted into the Hall on April 22nd?
  • Barry Mazor: My own suggestion would be that it probably wouldn't pay off to read those sorts of things into Kyle Young's …
  • A.B.: Barry's article was good. The quote from Mr Young mentioning Ralph Stanley is making me speculate though. He was probably …
  • Janice Brooks: got this album early this morning and added Frankie Please for now.
  • Daniel Mullins: I agree 100%. This is definitely one of Croweel's strongest albums. You can't help but feel more confident about yourself …
  • Juli Thanki: David, yep, I'd say it's his best since The Houston Kid; though I think I like the songwriting on here …
  • henry: He has a great story about "Fever on the Bayou," which I'm sure he told you about how long the …
  • Jonathan Pappalardo: Incredible album, exceptional review. Totally agree that this is his finest work in more than a decade.
  • David Cantwell: I can't wait to hear this, Juli. Just curious... When you say his best in more than a decade, I'm …
  • Joe Mekler: Not only is this a fun tune with an unusual form but it is politically appropriate for the present times!

Recently Reviewed Albums

  • rodneycrowelltarpapersky
  • rhondavincentonlyme
  • mandybgibson
  • paulburchfevers
  • kelliepicklerwomaniam
  • ronblockwalkingsong
  • lindiortegatinstar
  • timdarrell