Blake Shelton — “Sure Be Cool If You Did”

Karlie Justus Marlowe | January 23rd, 2013

blakesheltonSongwriters: Nicolle Clawson (aka Nicolle Galyon), Jimmy Robbins, and Chris Tompkins

Last year, Blake Shelton managed to nab the coveted CMA Entertainer of the Year award by leveraging his larger than life personality, social media savvy, and a spot on one of primetime television’s most popular talent shows. It was an interesting shift in the notion of where and how fans want to be entertained, proving that today’s round-the-clock digital culture doesn’t require headphones or concert tickets anymore to connect with their favorite musical artists.

Perhaps, then, Shelton is a new breed of country music star, one that doesn’t require music at all to be successful. It’s new territory, to be sure — after all, even Taylor Swift’s success is ground firmly in her songs and the conversations they spur.

That would certainly explain Shelton’s seeming detachment from his recent musical output, which seems to draw inspiration from all of the genres he’s exposed to each week during The Voice. He tried contemporary Christian on for size with 2011’s “God Gave Me You,” mixed it up with the machismo honky-tonk “Drink On It” to kick off 2012, and then tested out a smoother adult sound on “Over.” And now, on his first sampling of a new album due out later this year, he samples a bit of R&B in both production and phrasing.

“Sure Be Cool If You Did” is impressive in its adventurous spirit — after launching with opening line “I was gonna keep it real like chill like only have a drink or two,” its clap-like back beat goes on to share the stage with a mix of echoes, electric guitar and enough pick-up line innuendo to make the The Bellamy Brothers blush. It feels lazy, a flimsy foundation to Shelton’s strong vocals.

In the single’s favor, it does receive a boost from a strongly memorable chorus, punctated with the title lyrics and an undulating hit of guitar. It provides the sticking power the rest of the song is missing, jumbled together in a mish-mash of cliches (“You can’t shoot me down cause you’ve already knocked me dead”) and the worst girly-drink description since Tim McGraw’s “Felt Good on My Lips.”

If Shelton continues to find success without forging an identifiable sound that matches the early creative output that put him on the map, then maybe songs like “Sure Be Cool If You Did” will work just fine for him and his fans amidst his Twitter, TV and award show output. The rest of us will have to just listen to “Austin” and “Ol’ Red” through our old-fashioned stereo speakers.

Thumbs Down

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JUX2YIpH0r4

  1. bob
    January 23, 2013 at 8:11 am

    Great review. What a waste of talent. Sometimes a strong vocalist can make you overlook less than great material. Awful material is another story.

  2. Jon
    January 23, 2013 at 9:18 am

    “Last year, Blake Shelton managed to nab the coveted CMA Entertainer of the Year award by leveraging his larger than life personality, social media savvy, and a spot on one of primetime television’s most popular talent shows. It was an interesting shift in the notion of where and how fans want to be entertained, proving that today’s round-the-clock digital culture doesn’t require headphones or concert tickets anymore to connect with their favorite musical artists.”

    Given that the first sentence is purely speculative – CMA award ballots aren’t annotated with reasons for voters’ choices – what value does the second sentence’s “proving” actually have?

  3. Ben Foster
    January 23, 2013 at 11:20 am

    This song is like air to me. I get nothing out of it at all – which unfortunately has become my routine reaction to each new Blake Shelton single.

    and the worst girly-drink description since Tim McGraw’s “Felt Good on My Lips.”

    Ha!

  4. Mike Wimmer
    January 23, 2013 at 7:22 pm

    Scott Hendricks as Blake’s producer has really brought the quality of his work down. I’m not gonna blame it all on him, but the combination of Hendricks and Blake’s exploding popularity and his music has just fallen apart. Great vocal talent, but I can honestly list MAYBE 5 songs of his I have enjoyed since Pure BS. Even within those 5 songs, “Delilah” is the only one I can think off that instantly comes to mind.

  5. Bobby P.
    March 13, 2013 at 3:39 am

    Where the heck did you get “Nicolle Clawson” as the co-writer? BMI says Rodney Clawson.

Tagged In This Article

// // // // // // //

Current Discussion

  • luckyoldsun: Barry, That's a good point, as far as country itself being a word that refers to a lot more than a …
  • Six String Richie: Also, in regards to that article, Aldean's #2 complaint was "Nashville Copycats" and he gripes that people are copping Luke …
  • Six String Richie: Billboard misprinted his new single as "Burnin' It Up" in that article! That goes to show how little even …
  • CraigR.: Here are 5 things that piss me off about Jason Aldean: 1. He is a sore winner. Why complain when you …
  • Barry Mazor: The words "country" and jazz (or "jass") and blues had been around for decades before they became genres (or formats) …
  • Jeff Miller: Yeah, the first time I played Jimmie Rodgers for my wife & daughter- they were aghast that he was singing …
  • David Cantwell: I think it more helpful to think of Americana not as a genre but as a format--and, perhaps better, and …
  • Juli Thanki: That would definitely be better than Marvel's hilariously terrible Billy Ray Cyrus comic book, released in 1995. http://4thletter.net/2009/02/billy-ray-cyrus-the-marvel-comic-book-yes-really/
  • Applejack: "I’m sure there are many ways to lasso in and constrict any genre or format, any of them, so tightly …
  • Emily: Wow!! Fabulous! Love those boots and you all look stunning! xo

Recently Reviewed Albums

  • paulthorntooblessed
  • duhksbeyondtheblue
  • kelleymickwee
  • sandrarhodes
  • candi staton
  • sturgillsimpsonmetamodern
  • raypricebeautyis
  • rodneycrowelltarpapersky